0
  • TripAdvisor

  • Home

  • Order Online

    • All
    • Profane Pies
    • Shut the Cup Up Cakes
    • Cookies & Bars
    • Pies
    • A little Something Extra
    • Sparkling Mocktails
    • Quiche

  • In-Store Menu

  • Weddings & Events

  • Mother's Day Menu

  • About

    • Shipping Information
    • FAQS

  • Contact

  • More

    Get to Know
    Us Better

    Shop

    About

    Contact

    ​

    Visit Our Location

    9 Liberty Street, Newburyport, MA  01950

    Help

    Shipping

    FAQS

    Payment Methods

    Follow Us

    Facebook

    Instagram

    ​

    Be the first to get menu and bakery updates!

    Thanks for submitting!

    ©2020 Buttermilk Baking Company

    Back to top