Cakes & Pies

Signature Chocolate Cake

Chocolate Devil's Food Cake filled with Salted Caramel Ganache, frosted with Chocolate Buttercream

Available in Gluten Free

Sprinkle Cake

Vanilla Funfetti Cake with Vanilla Buttercream inside and out

Available in Gluten Free or Gluten and Dairy Free

Carrot Cake

Moist Layers of Carrot Cake Sandwiched between Fluffy Cream Cheese Frosting

Lemon Raspberry Cake

Vanilla Cake, Lemon Curd, Raspberries, Raspberry Buttercream

Cookie Dough Cake

Vanilla Chocolate Chip Cake filled with Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Frosted in Brown Sugar Buttercream

CUSTOM Cake Orders

We require a minimum 3 week notice on all CUSTOM orders.  If you are reading this and find yourself in a state of pure panic, give us a call and we will do our best to accommodate short notice orders.

Please reload

About Our Pies

We bake these babies to order! And, trust me they are worth ordering! If you know you are going to need a pie, please give us a call in advance.

The Standard Apple Pie

The REAL deal Mile High Apple Pie! Available with a Crumb Crust upon request.

Mint Chocolate Chip Pie

Mint Chocolate Chip Mousse, Chocolate Ganache, Whipped Cream

Rasberry White Chocolate Pie

White Chocolate Mousse, Raspberry Puree, Chocolate Ganache, Whipped Cream, Chocolate Cookie Crumb Crust.

Peanut Butter Pie

Peanut Butter Mousse, Chocolate Ganache, Peanut Butter Caramel and Whipped Cream in a Chocolate Cookie Crumb Crust

Chocolate Mousse Pie

Bittersweet Chocolate Mousse, Chocolate Ganache and Whipped Cream in Chocolate Cookie Crumb Crust

Wild Maine Blueberry Pie

The Local Favorite, available with a crumb crust upon request.

Pecan Bourbon Pie

Pecan Pie Spiked with Bourbon. Would you like yours with Chocolate?

Key Lime Pie

In a Graham Cracker Crumb Crust, also available in Gluten Free

Please reload


  • Blueberry

  • Double Berry Bran

  • Chocolate Chip

  • Seasonal Flavor

Gluten Free Muffins:

  • Banana Nut

  • Bakers Choice

Scones, Biscuits and Breads:

  • Cranberry Orange

  • Buttermilk and Honey Biscuits

  • Banana Bread

  • Cinnamon Swirl Crumb Cake



  • Plain

  • Chocolate

  • Ham Cheese


Hand Pies

  • Apple

  • Blueberry Almond

  • Bakers Choice


  • Bacon Cheddar

  • Spinach and Goat Cheese



  • Chocolate Chip

  • Browned Butter Shortbread

  • Peanut Butter

  • Ginger Molasses

  • Frosted Cutout Cookies

  • Oreos

  • Nutterbutter Cookies

  • French Macarons – Flavors Vary

  • Gluten Free Cookies

  • GF & DF Chocolate Chip

  • Biscotti

  • GF & DF Almond Clouds

  • GF & DF Coconut Macaroons

  • Dunkaroos

Bars and Whoopie Pies:

  • Cereal Bars (Flavors Vary)

  • Brownies

  • Blondies

  • Whoopie Pies

Cake Pops:

  • Flavors Vary Call or Stop in for Daily Selection

  • GF Cake Pops (Order Only)


  • Flavors Vary Call or Stop in for Daily Selection

  • GF Cupcakes (Order Only)

  • GF & DF Cupcakes (Order Only)

  • Mini Cupcakes (Order Only)

Pies & Cakes for 2:

  • Flavors Vary, Call or Stop in for Daily Selection

Weekend Specials:



Follow Us
  • Facebook - White Circle
  • Instagram - White Circle

​© 2019-2020 by Buttermilk Baking Company. Creative by AMG Design.