Small Batch, from Scratch,
with Love & a Pinch of Profanity!

We're so excited to announce that you can now order our delicious treats through our online store. If you're local to the Boston area come visit our bakeshop located in beautiful downtown Newburyport, MA.

Shop Our Fall Favorites

"Just a great bakery. The cakes are absolutely awesome and when it comes to unique cake designs with little instructions from customer, this place knows how to do it. Two cakes so far and looking for excuse to order another one. Yum!"

Mayte Rivre

Get to Know
Us Better




Visit Our Location

9 Liberty Street, Newburyport, MA  01950


Follow Us

©2020 Buttermilk Baking Company

  • TripAdvisor