In-Store Menu

Live locally? Stop in to shop in person!

We are always developing new products! Our day to day offerings may vary. 

We encourage pre-orders, if you're in the market for something specific.


  • Apple or Apple Crumb Pie

  • Wild Maine Blueberry Pie

  • Mixed Berry Pie

  • Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

  • Pecan Bourbon Pie (w. or w/o Chocolate)

  • Cherry Pie

  • Chocolate Mousse Pie

  • Peanut Butter Pie

  • Key Lime Pie (Graham Cracker or GF Coconut Crust)

  • Chicken Pot Pie (Fully Baked or BIY - Bake it Yourself)

We bake our pies to order, please allow 48 hours notice. Call or email to pre-order.


  • Signature Chocolate Cake

  • Sprinkle Cake

  • Red Velvet Cake

  • Carrot Cake

  • Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake

  • Cookies & Cream Cake

  • Strawberry Cake

We always have a selection of cakes to serve 6-8 on hand, if you need something larger or want a specific flavor, please call or email to pre-order. Please allow 5 days notice to pre-order.

Shut the Cup Up Cakes (cakes in a jar):

  • Signature Chocolate Cake

  • Birthday Cake

  • Red Velvet Cake

  • Carrot Cake

  • Cookies and Cream Cake

  • Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake


  • Flavors Vary - Call for availability or pre-order

Cake Pops:

  • Flavors Vary - Call for availability or pre-order

Friday & Saturday Specials:

  • Cinnamon Buns

  • Jelly Donuts

  •  Donut Specials - flavors vary, call for availability or pre-order


  • Wild Maine Blueberry Muffin

  • Chocolate Chip Muffin

  • Cinnamon Swirl Crumb Cake

  • French Toast Bundt

  • GF Banana Nut Muffin


  • Cranberry Orange Scone


  • Buttermilk & Honey Biscuits


  • Bacon Cheddar Quiche

  • Spinach Goat Cheese Quiche


  • Plain Croissant

  • Chocolate Croissant

  • Ham & Cheese Croissant

  • Pepperoni Pizza Croissant

  • Nutella Croissant

  • Almond Croissant

  • Apple Pie Croissant


  • Peanut Butter Sandwich

  • Browned Butter Shortbread

  • Raspberry Thumbprint

  • Almond Cloud

  • Coconut Macaroon

  • GF Chocolate Chip

  • Chocolate Chip

  • Ginger Molasses

  • French Macarons - Flavors vary, call for availability or pre-order

Bar Cookies:

  • Brownies

  • Peanut Butter Fluff Bars

  • Unicorn Bars

More Treats:

  • Cookie Decorating Kits

  • Dunkaroos

  • Jarred Caramel Sauce

  • Pie Fries

  • Our Own Vanilla Extract

Get to Know
Us Better




Visit Our Location

9 Liberty Street, Newburyport, MA  01950


Follow Us

©2020 Buttermilk Baking Company

  • TripAdvisor