top of page

Home
Easter Menu
In-Store Menu
Weddings & Events
Birthdays & Parties
About
- FAQS
Contact
More

Use tab to navigate through the menu items.

Small Batch, From Scratch & Pinch of Profanity

Birthday Sparkler Candles
Price$11.00
Mingle Blackberry Hibiscus Bellini Mocktail
Price$12.95
Mingle Cranberry Cosmo Sparkling Mocktail
Price$12.95
TOST ROSE Non-Alcoholic Refresher
Price$12.95
TOST Non-Alcoholic Refresher
Price$12.95
Birthday Box
Price$50.00
Shut the Cup Up Sampler 6-Pack
Price$55.00
Cookies & Cream 6-Pack
Price$55.00
Chocolate Peanut Butter 6-Pack
Price$55.00
Happy Birthday Topper
Price$2.00
Red Velvet 6-Pack
Price$55.00
I'm F***in Sorry Pie
Price$15.00
Sorry I'm a D*** Pie
Price$15.00
Badass B**** Pie
Price$15.00
F*** YEA Pie
Price$15.00
F*** It All Pie
Price$15.00
F*** Pie
Price$15.00
Don't Be a D*** Pie
Price$15.00
C Word Pie
Price$15.00
Our Own Vanilla Extract
Price$20.00

Get to Know
Us Better

Shop

Visit Our Location

9 Liberty Street, Newburyport, MA 01950

Help

Payment Methods

Follow Us

Be the first to get menu and bakery updates!

Thanks for submitting!

©2021 Buttermilk Baking Company

bottom of page